Wednesday, June 15, 2022
HomeExclusiveIs Seltzer Water Bad For Your Kidneys

Is Seltzer Water Bad For Your Kidneys

Quick Read How Sparkling Water Compares To Regular Water

The Truth About Sparkling Water – Is Carbonated Water Bad for Your Health?
  • As long as there are no added sugars, sparkling water is just as healthy as still water.
  • Unlike sodas, carbonated waters dont affect your bone density or greatly damage teeth.
  • They can make you feel gassy or bloated, so you may want to avoid them if you have gastrointestinal issues.
  • Try flavoring regular water with fruit or herbs if you want to avoid the fizzy stuff.

To drink or not to drink? Thats the health-conscious question were asking about so many of our beverages these days.

By now, you probably know that sugar-laden sodas and juices are out, coffee is perfectly fine in moderation, and water should be everyones ride or die when it comes to calorie-free thirst quenching. But where does that leave the beverage hybrid that is sparkling water?

While the bubbly stuff is often considered a healthy alternative to soda, some worry that sparkling water isnt as hydrating as still water and can negatively impact your bone density and cause tooth decay.

Those concerns havent seemed to cause seltzer sales to fizzle out though. In 2018, the carbonated water industry grew by 13% to reach an estimated $2.2 billion value. Can all those LaCroix lovers really be wrong?

To help settle these water wars, Anne Linge, a registered dietitian nutritionist and certified diabetes educator at the Nutrition Clinic at University of Washington Medical Center-Roosevelt, steps in to pour on the nutritional knowledge.

Soda Causes Kidney Stones

MYTH BUSTED: While we are tempted to let you believe this one as Soda is a nutrient empty, sugar-laden drink, we must inform you this is NOT the case. The fact is phosphoric acid is the culprit that is an ingredient in SOME sodas, typically colas, and pepper sodas such as Coke or Dr. Pepper and Pepsi. The other issue with Soda is that it is a diuretic because of the caffeine. This makes the salt content in your urine rise, which promotes kidney stones. So have a soda, but also follow it with an equal amount of water and you will decrease that concentrate. Alternatively, you could avoid soda altogether and replace it with healthier alternatives.

Does Carbonated Water Cause Ibs

While it wont cause IBS, drinking carbonated water may lead to bloating and gas, which can lead to IBS flare-ups if youre sensitive to carbonated beverages.

The bottom line: If you have stomach issues and experience flare-ups after drinking carbonated water, you may be better off eliminating this beverage from your diet.

Also Check: Does Red Wine Cause Kidney Stones

Read Also: Can A Kidney Infection Cause Diarrhea

Still Water Vs Sparkling Water

For Pillepich, her concern is more about peoples daily fluid intake rather than labeling sparkling water.

If sparkling water is appealing and tastes good to someone and is going to help them stay hydrated, then I would say drink it, she says.

Sparkling water can be a great alternative for people who want to quit drinking sodas, which have high sugar content and acids. Although carbonated water also contains phosphoric or citric acid, which can harm the teeth, its acid level is lower than that of many sports drinks and sodas.

However, replacing soda with sparkling water doesnt work for everyone.

Karisa Karmali, a certified personal trainer and founder of Self-Love and Fitness, had swapped soda for sparkling water to reduce her sugar intake. But she felt pain in her teeth and gums as well as stomach bloating when she drank sparkling water.

When sparkling water is sold as the only alternative to soda, people miss the gray area, Karmali says.

Instead of carbonated water, she now opts for flavored still water infusedwith apples, berries, and citrus for a refreshing alternative.

Is Carbonated Water Bad For Your Kidneys

Is Carbonated Water Bad for Stage 3 Kidney Disease ...

there is lots said about carbonated water every now and then. If you take a look at what most people say, you will find mixed reactions. There are large numbers of people who simply disagree that carbonated water can harm the human body. You shall find several people addicted to carbonated water and refuse to intake regular pure form of water. Drinking carbonated water in moderation is good, but making it a part of your daily life may have adverse effect on your body.

The main function of kidneys is to remove the waste from your system and also help your body get rid of excess water. Carbonated water is high on carbon dioxide gas and thus creates pressure on kidney. Also the digestive system finds it hard to digest carbonated water, making you visit the wash room frequently. Frequently giving out water can lead to dehydration. Thus carbonated water can never serve the purpose of drinking water. It is fine to drink occasionally just for fun, but having it in place of water is not a healthy idea.

As kidney takes a long time to process the carbonated drinks and water, one must make it a habit to have it less often. It may take away your thirst for a while, but it will give your system a hard time to digest it. Carbonated water itself is high on carbon dioxide and can not filter the waste from the blood. Presence of too much of waste inside can spoil the functioning of your kidney and other organs. Thus make sure that you feed your body with regular water.

Also Check: Can You Have 4 Kidneys

Other Causes Of Kidney Disease

Kidney disease is commonly caused by diabetes or high blood pressure. Drinking carbonated beverages can contribute to excess weight, which is a risk factor for developing Type 2 — adult-onset — diabetes, and indirectly, kidney disease. The American Kidney Fund notes that you can inherit a type of kidney disease called polycystic kidney disease. Drinking soda may increase the risk of related diseases such as diabetes consult your doctor or nutritionist about the best diet plan for you.

References

Foods Which Are Worst For Kidneys

As our kidneys filter out toxins and excess acid from the blood, they also put a buffer or acid neutralizer back into the bloodstream in the form of bicarbonate. Here are foods bad for kidneys

This shows how crucial it is for your system to be alkaline, and its also why the kidneys get overworked when, for example, you take a lot of medications and/or eat an acid-forming diet.

And just as there are certain foods that help cleanse and alkalize the body and ease the load on the kidneys, there are foods bad for kidneys that are not only acidic, but actually damage these important organs.

In fact, regularly eating a lot of unhealthy foods bad for kidneys can increase the strain on your kidneys and even damage structures within your kidneys over time.

Even if you have kidney disease, you can benefit from improving your diet and lifestyle as well as looking after your health the way your doctor advises. You can continue to live productively for years without any major complications. Here are foods bad for kidneys.

You May Like: Kidney Sickness Symptoms

Does Carbonated Water Affect Bone Health

Many people believe that carbonated beverages are bad for bones because of their high acid content. However, research suggests the carbonation isnt to blame.

A large observational study in over 2,500 people found that cola was the only beverage associated with significantly lower bone mineral density. Carbonated water appeared to have no effect on bone health .

Unlike carbonated water and clear soda, cola drinks contain a lot of phosphorus.

The researchers proposed that the cola drinkers may have been consuming too much phosphorus and insufficient calcium, providing a potential risk factor for bone loss.

In another study, teen girls who consumed carbonated drinks were found to have lower bone mineral density. This was attributed to beverages that replaced milk in their diet, resulting in inadequate calcium intake .

In a controlled study in 18 postmenopausal women, drinking 34 ounces of sodium-rich sparkling water daily for 8 weeks led to better calcium retention than drinking plain mineral water (

Additionally, no negative effects on bone health were observed in the sparkling water group.

Animal research suggests carbonated water may even improve bone health.

Supplementing hens diets with carbonated water for 6 weeks led to increased leg bone strength compared with tap water .

Summary

Drinking carbonated cola drinks may harm bone health, but plain sparkling water appears to have a neutral or positive effect.

What Is The Most Flavorful Sparkling Water

Can carbonated water jeopardize kidneys? | VERIFY

The 10 Best Sparkling Waters , According to Taste LaCroix. San Pellegrino. Perrier. Spindrift. Mountain Valley. Poland Spring. Schweppes. Schweppesline of sparkling water beverage has a nice pop and fizz thats creamy in the way it froths. Adirondack Seltzer . Experience something fresh and natural with Adirondack, which is calorie- and sodium-free.

Also Check: Ginger Tea Dissolves Kidney Stones

Don’t Miss: What Laxative Is Safe For Kidneys

What Happens If You Drink Too Much Carbonated Water

Well, that depends on how much you re drinking . Sip a sparkling glass or two and you re completely fine the drink is all-natural, zero-calorie, and ultimately hydrating. But if you re guzzling can after can at your desk, it could be time to slow down. For one, carbonation can cause some serious bloating and gas.

Potential Risks Of Sparkling Water

If you dont like plain water, sparkling water is a good alternative to sugary sodas and fruit juices. The healthiest type of sparkling water is unflavored and unsweetened.

Watch out for products that include additives or sweeteners. These types of sparkling water can cause side effects for some people:

Sparkling waters that are high in sugar can cause tooth decay. But plain sparkling water has minimal effects on your teeth, especially compared to drinking soda. You can further prevent tooth decay by maintaining a good oral hygiene routine and by alternating sparkling water with plain water to cleanse your enamel.

Don’t Miss: How To Know If You Have Bad Kidneys

Help With Weight Loss

One of the biggest benefits of proper hydration is that it helps with weight loss. Drinking enough water can help you feel fuller for longer. It can also increase your metabolic rate, allowing you to burn more calories when resting. Need to avoid long-term weight gain? Water can help with this too. So, instead of reaching for the sugary sodas, grab a bottle of sparkling water instead.

Effect On Kidney Stones

Carbonated Water Vs. Flat Water for Healthy Kidneys ...

The good news is that drinking cola does not raise your risk of kidney stones. Research published in the “Journal of Endourology” in 2009 determined that drinking diet caffeine-free cola did not cause kidney stones in healthy adults. Kidney stones are typically formed from substances such as calcium, oxalate, creatinine and sodium and can lead to pain, inflammation and kidney damage.

Read Also: Does Red Wine Cause Kidney Stones

Is Perrier Bad For You

Perrier is carbonated bottled mineral water sourced from the Les Bouillens spring in Southern France. Although the water from the spring is already naturally carbonized, carbonic gas is added to it again as it is bottled. Because of the many health benefits this water promises, it became very popular among Americans who wanted to lead a healthy and active lifestyle. Perrier soon became a widely-used substitute for soft drinks or cocktails and has gained a reputation for being an all-natural, refreshing, zero-calorie drink. But there are people who believe that Perrier is bad for your dental and digestive health. Is this true?

Is Sea Salt Or Kosher Salt Better Than Table Salt

FAQTagskosher saltsaltsea saltSodiumtable salt

Sea salt features a coarse texture and stronger flavor compared to table salt. Sea salt is made from evaporated seawater, so sea salt contains traces of additional minerals and is natural instead of processed. Kosher salt has large crystals and contains no preservatives. Kosher salt can be derived from seawater or underground sources. Table salt has fine granules and is mined from underground salt deposits. Table salt is processed with anti-caking agent to prevent clumping. Some table salts are fortified with iodine, a mineral important for thyroid hormones.

While there are textural and processing differences in sea salt, kosher salt and table salt, all of these salts share one thing in common all are high in sodium. While none of these salts is lower in sodium, due to the size of the sea salt and kosher salt crystals, a measured teaspoon will contain less sodium compared to the fine granules in table salt. When following a low sodium diet, all salt should be limited. However, using larger textured sea salt and kosher salt may help reduce sodium by a very small amount.

Read Also: Does Red Wine Cause Kidney Stones

You May Like: Can Seltzer Water Cause Kidney Stones

When To Cut Down On Seltzer

Dr. Gause recommends skipping the seltzer if you already have an acidic diet, consuming lots of lemon juice, pomegranate, grapefruits, tomatoes, blueberries, pineapples, apples, corn, mushrooms, broccoli, etc.

Might I add that these are all foods I eat in great quantity, so I certainly need to cut down. I also have IBS, and the carbonation in seltzer can cause further irritation.

People who have IBS and or a sensitive GI may want to steer clear of carbonated water.

People who have IBS and or a sensitive GI may want to steer clear of carbonated water, says Feller, with Marinucci adding, If someone is experiencing digestive symptoms like feeling gassy/bloated/has a hiatal hernia and continues to consume seltzer with symptoms then that would be considered too much.

Also, if a person is using it to fill up and intentionally skip multiple meals/snacks then that is too much because every skipped meals/snacks are missed opportunities to fuel the body with nutrient dense foods, says Marinucci.

What Are The Benefits Of Carbonated Water

Is Carbonated Water Bad For You | The Truth About Sparkling Water

Here’s the best news: While sparkling water is carbonated, it still has the same hydrating effects as still water. “Sparkling water is just as hydrating as regular water and contributes to your daily water intake,” says Stefani Sassos, MS, RDN,a registered dietitian for the Good Housekeeping Institute. “If youre bored of regular tap water, incorporating sparkling water into your routine can change things up and help you hit your daily water quota.”

Additionally, most sparkling waters can be a much healthier alternative to soft drinks, as long as they don’t contain any sweeteners or added sugars which is something you’ll need to check for via the nutrition facts label. If you’ve found a product that’s free of major amounts of sugar, sodium or artificial flavoring, craving “fizz” on its own isn’t harmful for most, as it’s not only hydrating but also typically contains less sugar and calories than soda.

You May Like: The Functional Units Of The Kidneys Are

What Are The Ingredients In Seltzer Water

3.9/5sodiumsodiumsodium bicarbonatemore on it

Seltzer is simply carbonated water: Flat water that get an addictive effervescence from carbon dioxide. Club soda, typically used in cocktails, has a more mineral-y flavor from chemical compounds, like sodium bicarbonate and potassium sulfate.

Also Know, what is the difference between sparkling water and seltzer water? The main difference between seltzer and sparkling water comes down to where the carbonation comes from. If the carbonation is artificial, it’s probably seltzer or club soda and regulated like a soda. If the bubbles are naturally occurring, straight from the source, it’s sparkling water.

Considering this, is there a downside to drinking sparkling water?

The only downside to soda water is that it’s slightly acidic, and scientists speculate that it might erode tooth enamel. So to protect your pearly whites, choose regular water, which has no acid but can be fortified with good-for-your-teeth fluoride.

Is seltzer water good to drink?

Artificial carbonation is a sign of seltzer or club soda. Naturally occurring bubbles are characteristic of sparkling water. That said, seltzer water can be a wonderful way to stay hydrated especially if you’re not in the mood for regular water. Hollenstein says seltzer isn’t inherently healthy or unhealthy.

What Are The 3 Main Types Of Bubbly Water

Carbonated waters that do not contain sweeteners or calories are the best choice for someone wanting to care of their liver. The fizzy water options can be a bit confusing, because not all bubbly water is the same.

The three main types are:

  • Sparkling Mineral Water This water is bottled at the source, which means that it has naturally occurring minerals and carbonation. The bubbles are typically fine and delicate, creating a slight effervescent texture. Mineral water is less acidic than other fizzy waters, but because its sourced naturally and often imported, it tends to cost a bit more. Sparkling mineral water may contain some sodium, so those on a sodium-restricted diet must be aware of this.
  • Seltzer Also called sparkling water, seltzer is carbonated artificially and typically has bigger, sharper bubbles. In general, seltzer contains no ingredients other than water. However, some brands add natural flavors.
  • Club Soda Like seltzer, club soda is carbonated artificially but has more additions like salt, potassium bicarbonate, and potassium sulfate. Thus, club soda has a slightly salty, mineral taste. Again, those on a sodium-restricted diet must be aware of this.
  • Also Check: Whats Renal

    Promote Good Bowel Movements

    Another benefit of drinking more water is that you promote better bowel movements and a healthier digestive system. Another link was found between dehydration and constipation in people of all ages.

    Not only can drinking more water help relieve constipation, but researchers have also concluded that drinking carbonated water is more helpful than spring water in reducing the effects of constipation.

    Pretzels Chips And Crackers

    Is Seltzer Water Bad for Your Teeth? â Gary Nack, DDS

    Ready-to-eat snack foods like pretzels, chips, and crackers tend to be lacking in nutrients and relatively high in salt.

    Also, its easy to eat more than the recommended portion size of these foods, often leading to even greater salt intake than intended.

    Whats more, if chips are made from potatoes, theyll contain a significant amount of potassium as well.

    SUMMARY

    Pretzels, chips, and crackers are easily consumed in large portions and tend to contain high amounts of salt. Additionally, chips made from potatoes provide a considerable amount of potassium.

    Read Also: Can Aleve Damage Your Kidneys

    RELATED ARTICLES

    Most Popular