Which Is Better Whey Or Pea Protein
Pea and whey protein powders are both rich sources of protein, though whey powder does tend to have a slightly higher amount. Theyre also both relatively low in carbs, fat, fiber, and sugar. Because its made from milk, whey protein has more calcium and potassium. On the other hand, pea protein has more iron.16 mar. 2021
High Biological Proteins Is Outdated
Old nutrition ideas used to swear by the thought that we needed to eat proteins that had high biological value aka animal proteins or paired plant proteins.
What we know now is that our body does a wonderful job at storing amino acids in a pool in our body that can be paired up and used as needed. No longer do we need to eat rice and beans at the same meal as long as we eat a variety in our diet our body can manage quite well!
In fact, many with chronic kidney disease should be focusing on a low protein diet rather than focusing on getting more protein.
The Benefits Of A Plant
Research published in the American Journal of Kidney Diseases suggests that eating plant-based protein sources instead of meat could play a significant role in improving the health of people with declining kidney function.
Vegetarian diets are believed to reduce the protein content in urine, the renal acid load , and renal hyperfiltration . The reduction of these factors help prevent kidney disease as well.
The National Kidney Foundation also states that CKD patients who follow a plant-based diet are at an advantage of slowing down the progression of their kidney disease. These are other known benefits of eating plant-based protein sources:
- Allows you to maintain a healthy weight
- Lowers blood pressure and cholesterol levels, reducing the risk of heart disease
- Aids your body to use insulin better and ward off diabetes risk
- Nourishes your body with antioxidants to prevent cell damage
Meatless protein sources that provide you with all the vitamins and nutrients your body needs are called complete proteins. These foods are packed with essential amino acids which are proteins converted by your body to build your cells, muscles, and organs.
Recommended Reading: Is Mio Bad For Your Kidneys
Risks And Side Effects
The American Diabetic Association states that well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes, assuming that enough protein, omega-3s, iron and B vitamins are consumed.
That said, some vegan proteins are better than others. Many meat-avoiders turn to soy-based products for protein, including tofu, soy milk, soy protein powders and edamame.
Soy-rich foods are unfortunately commonly genetically modified and can even operate as hormone disruptors .
If you are a pregnant mother, you might want to know that eating proteins specifically from meat is linked with healthier birth weights, especially later in pregnancy. Consult your OB/GYN about dietary choices during pregnancy if you have any concerns about this.
A vegan diet can also be potentially harmful for young children with risks of inadequate supply in terms of protein quality and energy, as well as fatty acids, iron, zinc, vitamin D, iodine, calcium and vitamin B12.
Another thing to keep in mind is that some plant-based proteins are high in lectins, a group of antinutrients that can cause damage to the GI tract and interfere with absorption of nutrients.
Plant Based Protein Powder And Kidney Disease Throw It Out Or Use It Alternatives
This video is in response to a question we got in our email earlier today. CAN I USE A PLANT-BASED PROTEIN POWDER IF I HAVE KIDNEY DISEASE?
Now to start off, the answer to that question is Yes, but, there is a better option and thats what were going to talk about. Protein powders are typically suggested to people with kidney disease when they show low protein levels.
The issue with taking protein powder is that it puts a lot of stress on the kidneys. With vegetarian sources of protein powder, they may put less stress on the kidneys than animal-based protein sources.
Many plant-based protein powders are available on the market. Some made out of rice, peas, soy protein powders, and a whole bunch of other combinations. The protein they contain may put some stress on the kidneys but it will be easier than other animal-based protein sources.
In retrospect, taking a protein in a powder form may just end up hurting your kidneys as youll be consuming a lot of protein in one serving. This will wear out more kidney cells and may lead to more loss in your kidney function.
Now, were going to dive into an obscure option that is way better than taking plant-based or animal-based protein powder. A lot of patients and medical professionals are unaware of this discovery but a better option for intaking protein is to take essential amino acids. Amino acids make up protein and the essential ones are collected through ones diet.
You May Like: Can Seltzer Water Cause Kidney Stones
Can Pea Protein Make You Gain Weight
Pea protein for weight gain can be an important resource. Its lower in calories than a typical whey protein product, and its a better option than sugar-filled protein shakes on the market. It helps a person to gain lean body mass, not just any type of body mass, which is a healthier type of weight.
Potassium Is Not Bad In A Plant
One of the first recommendations a physician may give someone with kidney disease is stop eating potassium.
However, what studies are now showing is that even those with later-stages of kidney disease can benefit in not having such a significant restriction, especially if following a plant-based diet.
Potassium can help with blood pressure control, which is very helpful for your kidneys as high blood pressure is one of the top causes of kidney disease.
The highest sources of potassium in our diet come from fruit and vegetables. When following a plant-based diet, the goal is to have a base including fruits and vegetables.
A study in 2013 found that after one year of increased intakes of fruits and vegetables in those with stage 4 CKD found no impact on potassium levels, but did result in improved metabolic acidosis and better kidney health.
If your doctor has told you to limit potassium, it does not mean you cannot follow a plant-based diet. Work with a dietitian to learn your best potassium needs and goals to keep your kidneys healthy. Learn more about the low potassium diet here.
Read Also: Seltzer Kidney Stones
How Much Protein Do I Need To Eat Daily
Every person has unique nutrient requirements. The right amount of protein your body needs depends on your age, gender, weight, general health condition, and your CKD stage.
To give you an idea, below are estimates of how much protein do common plant sources contain according to the NKF:
|
½ cup steel cut oatmeal |
5 grams |
|
1 cup tofu |
11 grams |
IMPORTANT NOTE: If youre planning to switch to a plant-based diet, you must consult with your nephrologist or renal dietitian first before making any dietary adjustments. They will help you determine the exact amount of protein as well as the right food sources you need to consume.
Top 3 Plant Protein Supplements
The most popular protein supplements like whey protein and bone broth are animal-derived, but that doesnt mean you have to miss out on the great benefits of a protein supplement.
When it comes to the best vegan protein sources, several types of protein powders make the list because they are highly convenient and provide essential amino acids. In general, its a good idea to switch up what protein powders you use so you can benefit from the various nutrients found in each one.
Many experts believe that the best plant-based protein powders are hemp, pea and brown rice protein.
- Hemp protein powder is made from hemp seeds and has a bunch of fiber to accompany the other nutrients it provides. Its associated with a decreased risk of osteoporosis, a cleaner colon and immune system benefits.
- Pea protein is not technically a complete protein source but still offers great benefits, including your daily recommended vitamin D in just a serving. It also can help regulate your blood sugar, reduce your risk of kidney disease and aid in weight loss.
- Brown rice protein powder can support liver function, reduce glycemic response and aid in cholesterol regulation.
Also Check: Is Cranberry Juice Good For Your Liver And Kidneys
The Impacts Of Plant Protein On Chronic Kidney Disease
Libby Mitchell
Chronic kidney disease patients should consider adding more plant-based proteins such as beans and tofu to their diet. While eating animal protein was previously associated with a negative health effect on these patients, a new study shows that eating plant proteins can actually improve their health and lower their mortality rate.
In this study, we found every 33% increase in the plant to total protein ratio was associated with a statistically significant decreased risk of death in those with CKD, said Srinivasan Beddhu, MD, a nephrologist with University of Utah Health Care. Our research indicates that plant-based proteins could play an important role in improving the health outcomes for people with decreased kidney function.
While the impacts of adding plant protein are being seen it still is not clear why these impacts are occurring. One hypothesis is that the consumption of plant proteins lowers the production of uremic toxins. These toxins have been implicated in the progression of CKD, says Beddhu. They can also contribute to cardiovascular disease, and death in patients with kidney disease.
Another explanation deals with the levels of phosphorus in the body. Normal functioning kidneys remove phosphorous in the blood. However, in patients with CKD the phosphorous cannot remove the mineral and that can lead to leaching of calcium from the bones, and deposits of calcium on organs.
How Much Protein Do We Need
An average person needs 0.8 gram of protein daily per kilogram of bodyweight . So for example if you weigh 70 kg/ 155 lb, you need around 56 grams of protein a day. If youre building muscle, do challenging physical work or train hard, youll need to increase your protein intake up to 1.4-2 g per kg of body weight daily.
Its so easy to get enough protein on a plant-based diet that protein deficiency is virtually unheard of in developed countries. In fact, most of us get too much protein thats how easy it is.
Excellent sources of protein include soya products , black beans, kidney beans, baked beans, lentils, chickpeas, whole grains and products made from them , nuts and seeds of all types. Plant protein powders may also be useful if youre busy, prefer liquid meals or want to increase protein content of your meals.
You May Like: Does Red Wine Cause Kidney Stones
Is Vegan Protein Powder Bad For You
Melissa Piercell, ND, says that plant-based protein powder in moderation should be fine. The vegetable products used in vegan protein powders come from the ground. Because of that, they can bring up some heavy metals from the soil. Whats found in the protein powder isnt an added ingredient, its from the soil.
What Is A Plant
- The Mediterranean diet. This is a diet typical of many Mediterranean countries, such as Italy and Spain. It consists mainly of cereals, grains, vegetables, beans, fruits, and nuts, along with moderate amounts of fish, cheese, olive oil, yogurt, and little red meat.
- The DASH diet. This diet is often recommended for people with high blood pressure. It consists of eating fruits, vegetables, low-fat dairy foods, whole grains, fish, poultry, and nuts. It also limits sodium , sweets, sugary drinks, red meats, and foods that are high in saturated fat, cholesterol, and trans fats.
- The MIND diet. This diet combines the Mediterranean diet and the DASH diet to create a diet that focuses on brain health. Green leafy vegetables, berries, nuts, olive oil, whole grains, fish, beans, and poultry are the main focus.
Recommended Reading: What Is The Va Disability Rating For Kidney Disease
Is Hemp Protein Bad For Kidneys
Hemp protein may reduce kidney damage and prevent complications in people with kidney disease. In an animal study, kidney health improved in kidney-diseased rats fed hemp protein or soy protein diets, but not pea protein. In addition, the soy and hemp protein-fed rats had less heart damage due to kidney disease.
Recipes For Clean Kidneys
saltstorm/Flickr
For those who suffer from kidney disease, a diet low in potassium and phosphorus is key. A plant-based diet is the best way to avoid elevating phosphorus levels. If you do not suffer from kidney disease, but wish to improve maintain healthy kidneys, drinking lots of water and eating anti-inflammatory fruits, vegetables, legumes, and grains is optimal.
For some recipe inspiration, try some of these cleansing meals such as this Cranberry Apple Detox Juice, Stuffed Peppers with Vegetables, Wild Rice, and Lemongrass, Simple Basil Citrus Salad with Balsamic Jam Dressing, Homemade Raw Sauerkraut, or these Korean White Radish Wraps.
For more information, check out this article! We also recommend downloading this Food Monster App, which is available for both Android and iPhone and can also be found on and . The app has more than 10,000 plant-based, allergy-friendly recipes, and subscribers gain access to new recipes every day. Check it out!
Lead Image Source: John Campbell/Flickr
You May Like: Kidney Pain Std
How To Increase Anabolism Induced By Plant
13.1. Creating Diets Containing Different Plant Protein Sources to Provide a High Quality AA Profile
13.2. Combining Plant and Animal Proteins
13.3. Consumption of Greater Amounts of Plant Proteins
13.4. Supplementing Plant-Based LPD with Essential AA/KA
13.5. Genetic Engineering and Other Approaches to Improve the Quality of Plant Proteins
Patients With Ckd Debate Value Of Meat Plant
Disclosures: We were unable to process your request. Please try again later. If you continue to have this issue please contact .
For patients with chronic kidney disease or on dialysis, plant-based diets have been viewed as second rate to animal protein. It was believed that plant-based diets would cause phosphorus and potassium levels to rise and plant proteins could not meet the needs of the patient with kidney disease.
Studies support an increase of fruits and vegetables and plant-based proteins in the CKD and dialysis populations. Lower overall protein intake associated with vegetarians can help slow the progression of kidney disease without sacrificing nutritional status in CKD. A recent study by Bernier-Jean and colleagues revealed a slower decline in kidney function in a 10-year longitudinal study for older women with a plant-based protein diet. Potassium and phosphorus levels are better controlled on whole food plant-based diets, secondary to less exposure to phosphorus and potassium additives. There are several other benefits, such as anti-inflammatory factors, improvements in gut health and a decrease in acid load.
Check the ingredients
If you crave meat, make it meat
Valarie M. Hannahs
Those who are on more frequent hemodialysis or PD and those with transplants often have increased options when it comes to diet, but all can benefit from a whole food plant-based diet.
References:
Anjos JS, et al. J Ren Nutr. 2018 doi:10.1053/j.jrn.2017.11.005.
Recommended Reading: Std That Affects Kidneys
Plant Vs Animal Protein
Protein is the building block of life, made up of amino acids that our bodies use in virtually every internal process we have.
Is plant-based protein better for you than animal protein? Both sources of protein have their benefits. For example, vegan protein is sustainable and often low in calories but high in fiber, while animal foods are more dense in essential amino acids.
Because their genetic makeup is more similar to ours than plants, animals protein is most easily digested by the human body. Fish, eggs, raw dairy or any meats provide protein that your body knows how to process.
Plant-based protein, on the other hand, is a little less digestible for the human body. Sources of protein from plants also rarely contain a complete amino acid profile, meaning that they contain all 20 necessary amino acids, including the nine that are essential.
Since plant protein shows up in smaller quantities than animal protein, choosing a plant-based diet requires intentionality. It is definitely possible to get all the nutrients you need from only plant foods, as long as you put thought into your meal planning.
Your best bet is paying attention to your own individual biofeedback to determine whats best for your body.
For example, while people interested in bodybuilding or building large amounts of muscle mass may have a harder time going completely plant-based, even they can usually still achieve their goals with the right planning and focus.
Is Plant Based Protein Better For Kidneys
Is Plant Based Protein Better For Kidneys. About 20% of the human body is made up of protein. But then the questions start coming.
Unless you’re eating a ton of protein over a long period of time, most people will never have an issue. Topping the list are the health benefits, including weight loss and reduced risk of cancer and heart disease. So plant proteins spare the kidneys, except for pea protein. However, a vegetarian renal diet requires a tailored meal plan from a registered dietitian because vegetarian sources of protein also contain varying amounts of potassium and phosphorus. Global icon elle macpherson presents welleco.
Also Check: Is Mulberry Good For Kidneys
General Health Benefits Of Pea Protein
Pea protein is as you would expect is derived from green and yellow split peas in powder form and it serves as a source of protein. Pea protein is a great option for people who react to other sources of protein because it isnt gotten from allergic foods like eggs, fish, nuts, peanuts, etc. Pea proteins are easy to digest and are rich in iron for muscle building. More often now, pea protein powder serves as a base for smoothies, ice cream, mayo, and so on.
Youre probably wondering what the difference is between eating normal peas and consuming the protein powder. The protein is isolated from the pea in powder form so it provides all the health benefits and prevents bloating and gassiness. A single serving of pea protein powder can provide you with 17-24 grams of protein and 90-20 calories.