Tuesday, May 21, 2024
HomePopularDoes Milk Cause Kidney Stones

Does Milk Cause Kidney Stones

Four Main Kinds Of Kidney Stones

Expert busts myth that fresh milk tea causes kidney stones

There are four main kinds of kidney stones:

  • Calcium oxalate stones, by far the most common type of kidney stone

  • Calcium phosphate stones, also very common

  • Uric acid stones, often associated with diabetes

  • Struvite stones, often caused by an active infection

The two most common kidney stones include calcium’ in their names, so does that mean you should cut out milk and other calcium-rich foods?

Soymilk And Kidney Stones

Nephrolithiasis, or kidney stones, is the presence of renal calculi caused by a disruption in the balance between solubility and precipitation of salts in the urinary tract and in the kidneys.; Approximately 10% of people participating in the 20132014 National Health and Nutrition Examination reported having kidney stones. The highest prevalence was observed in males older than 60 years, at 17.8%, followed by males 4059 years old at 12.6%.1; Diet plays a huge role in the prevention and management of kidney stones.2

A recent publication by Borin et al.3 concluded that oat, macadamia, rice, and soy milk compare favorably in terms of kidney stone risk factors with dairy milk, whereas almond and cashew milk have more potential stone risk factors. Let us take a look at the various dietary factors that impact kidney stone risk and the composition of plant milks.

Dietary sodium restriction decreases urinary calcium excretion7,8 so recommendations are to limit sodium intake to no more than 3g/d.2 In comparison to cows milk, three plant milks contain more sodium than milk, four contain similar amounts , one is moderately lower and two contain much less .

Nutrient content per cup of cows milk and selected plant milks


Does Drinking Milk Cause Kidney Stones

Kidneys stones are a common condition. Men have a 13 percent risk and women have a 7 percent risk of developing kidneys stones in their lifetime.;A person with a history of kidney stones has a 50 percent risk of recurrence in the first five years;and an 80 percent recurrence at 10 years.

The risk factors for kidney stones include:

  • Inadequate fluid intake
  • Family history of kidney stones
  • Recurrent urinary tract infections
  • Diseases such as;Crohns disease, hyperparathyroidism, or gout

Some believe that drinking milk can increase the risk of kidney stones. However, its a mere myth and has no scientific basis. It is believed that calcium in the milk can accumulate and result in stone formation in the kidneys. However, the fact is that milk can actually protect the kidneys.

Recommended Reading: Is Watermelon Good For Dogs With Kidney Disease

Common Side Effects People Have Besides Kidney Stones *:

  • Neuropathy Peripheral : 4 people, 23.53%
  • Pain: 4 people, 23.53%
  • Compression Fracture : 3 people, 17.65%
  • Osteomyelitis : 3 people, 17.65%
  • Immunodeficiency: 3 people, 17.65%
  • Hepatic Cirrhosis : 3 people, 17.65%
  • Haematochezia : 3 people, 17.65%
  • Psoriasis : 3 people, 17.65%
  • Sleep Disorder: 3 people, 17.65%
  • Facts About Kidney Stones

    Does Milk Cause Kidney Stones?
  • Calcium doesnt cause kidney stones. In moderation, eating calcium can actually help prevent stones from forming.
  • Its more common than you think.; One in 10 people will develop a kidney stone in their lifetime and 85 percent will develop them again within 10 years. Men develop stones more often than women.
  • Save that stone. If you pass a stone, save it for testing. There are different types of kidney stones. By knowing what specific type of stone you had, we can tailor prevention recommendations for your individual needs.
  • One size does not fit all.; Kidney stones can be as small as a grain of salt or as big as a golf ball.; Different treatments are recommended for the various sizes of stones.
  • Prevention is key.; Changes in diet and medication, if indicated, are about 90 percent effective in preventing new stones from forming.
  • You May Like: Is Pineapple Good For Kidney Stones

    Ways To Prevent Kidney Stones

    All that said, there are some always-good-for-you options that can also help prevent stones.

    Here’s a short list of recommendations to consider.

    • Fluids of all types are safe, because they increase urine output and that’s a big goal. Dilute urine is your best friend in preventing stones, so drink up.

    • There are benefits to balance, so eat more fruits and vegetables. “I can’t think of a reason why they wouldn’t be safe for anybody,” said Penniston. “A variety of fruits and vegetables can provide stone prevention benefits for most people. There are some foods like fruits and vegetables that, if we eat more of them, can reduce some of the major risk factors of most types of stones.”

    • Bacteria can be a good thing. The gut microbiome is the hottest new topic when it comes to nutrition. And it turns out that the bacteria that live in our GI tract probably do have a lot more to do with our overall health than we think.”Some of the therapy that we do is aimed at optimizing the gut microbiome, and to do that you have to eat foods that will sustain a healthy colonization of bacteria, like fiber and fruits and vegetables,” said Penniston. “Cultured foods like yogurt, and kefir or fermented foods aid the microbiome directly by introducing more bacteria into the digestive tract.”

    Is Milk Good For Kidney Stones

    The majority of the kidney stones found are made up of calcium oxalate. These are formed when the pH of urine is acidic, and the calcium oxalate crystallizes from urine. The patient is advised to stay away from the foods containing oxalate such as beet, soy products, spinach, sweet potato, nuts, and black pepper. However, there are some arguments for and against regarding the use of calcium supplements and dietary calcium in the patients with kidney stones.

    Also Check: Can Kidney Transplant Patients Get Tattoos

    As Always Consult Your Physician

    If you feel you may be suffering from kidney stone symptoms, your first course of action should always be to consult your physician. Dr. Cornell is a well-respected, board certified urologist serving the greater Houston area. Contact our office today to get a referral if you are suffering from urinary or kidney pain.

    Do You Think Calcium From Milk Will Aggravate Kidney Stones Then You Need To Read This

    Does A High Protein Diet Cause Kidney Damage or Stones (Clinical Evidence Included)

    Written by Debjani Arora | Published : May 13, 2016 3:56 PM IST

    This is one of the most common concerns for those who suffer from kidney stones. Since milk and other dairy products are rich in calcium, the general perception is it can increase one s chances of suffering from kidney stones, especially, calcium stones . However, the reverse is true. If you lack calcium in your diet, it can increase your chances of suffering from kidney stones.

    In the digestive tract, calcium binds with oxalate from food sources and prevents it from entering the blood and the urinary tract where the stones are formed. For people suffering from kidney stones who are under treatment, a normal intake of milk say, one glass of milk or a cup of yoghurt or other dairy products might not do any harm. The idea is to have dairy products in moderation,’ says Dr Anup Ramani, Uro-Oncological & Robotic Surgeon, Lilavati, Breach Candy, Saifee Hospital.

    Don’t Miss: Is Pomegranate Juice Good For Your Kidneys

    Tips To Avoid Kidney Stones

    • Drink plenty of fluid, especially water. This is the most important thing you can do to lower your risk of getting another kidney stone. Aim for at least 2 ½ liters to 3 liters of fluid each day. People with cystine stones may want to aim for 4 liters .
    • It may be helpful to limit animal protein, including meat, fish, seafood, poultry, and eggs.
    • Eat calcium-rich foods instead of taking supplements.
    • If you want to take a vitamin C supplement, make sure you take less than 1000 milligrams per day. High amounts of vitamin C may increase your risk of stones.

    Do Dairy Products Cause Kidney Stones

    Im just a cow, doing cow stuff.

    We know two facts about kidney stones:

  • Nearly 80% of kidney stones are calcium based, according to the National Institutes of Health
  • Milk has a lot of calcium; an 8 ounce glass of milk contains about;300 mg of calcium, according to;Harvard University Health Services
  • So the logic should follow that consumption of more calcium should increase the chances of getting kidney stones, right?

    Nope. In fact, it is just the opposite, at least for calcium oxalate stones, the most common stone by far. ;It appears that calcium that comes from our food and beverages is actually beneficial, according to a study from the University of Wisconsin.

    Our body does three major things with calcium:

  • Stores it in our bones and teeth
  • Uses it to help our muscles move and our nerves to function
  • Gets rid of it
  • Oxalate is a chemical that is found in a number of foods, such as spinach, nuts, tea, and chocolate. ;When consumed together with calcium, such as that from dairy products, the oxalate binds with excess calcium that is not stored or used in the intestines and passes harmlessly out of the body.

    If there is not enough calcium in the intestines, i.e. its being absorbed by your body, then the oxalate passes into your kidneys and hooks up with any calcium atoms it can find, forming the crystals that are the starting point for kidney stones.

    You May Like: Kidney Medical Definition

    What Causes Kidney Stones

    There are many causes of kidney stones, but they often form when urine becomes concentrated with minerals and lacks in potassium citrate. Some bacterial urine infections also raise the pH of urine, which precipitates the minerals. Kidney stones are primarily a disease found in developed countries rather than developing or poor countries, which is probably due to diets containing excessive calories, processed meat, salt, fructose , beer and spirits.;

    Lower Your Animal Protein Intake

    Misconception: Drinking Milk Causes Kidney Stones

    Many sources of protein, such as red meat, pork, chicken, poultry, fish, and eggs, increase the amount of uric acid you produce. Eating large amounts of protein also reduces a chemical in urine called citrate. Citrates job is to prevent the formation of kidney stones. Alternatives to animal protein include quinoa, tofu , hummus, chia seeds, and Greek yogurt. Since protein is important for overall health, discuss how much you should eat daily with your doctor.

    Don’t Miss: What Is The Functional Unit Of The Kidney

    Four Myths About Kidney Stones

    If you’ve ever had a run-in with kidney stones, then you’ve also had a run-in with a relative/neighbor/obnoxious over-sharer who has the home remedy that fixed them right up.

    And while unsolicited after-dinner medical advice may sometimes sound reasonable, there’s a lot you need to know about your own kidney stones before you start adjusting your diet based on Aunt Alice’s latest stone story.

    “You don’t want calcium because that’s what stones are made of, so ditch the milk.””Oxalates are bad, so stop eating foods like chocolate, beer, soy, nuts, spinach and coffee.””And if you feel a stone coming on, start drinking lots of cranberry juice to get rid of it.”

    You’ve probably gathered lots of advice and home remedies in your battle against kidney stones . But many of grandma’s homemade fixes may actually do more harm than good when it comes to the specific composition of your kidney stones and the reasons why you are forming them.

    What are kidney stones? They’re crystal-like formations of the excess minerals in your urine. This simple answer leads to simplified and problematic responses. The logic: Identify what you’re consuming, and reduce whatever the stone is made of.

    Milk And Kidney Stones: The Truth

    In a study, people with a history of kidney stones;gave up milk and milk products believing that milk causes kidney formation. However, even after giving up milk, their urinary calcium levels did not decrease, implying that milk consumption is not related to ;kidney stones.

    Though calcium supplements may pose a risk of developing kidney stones, the dietary supplements of;calcium;are always protective for the kidneys.

    Read Also: What Are The Three Main Regions Of The Kidney

    Kidney Stone Diet Plan And Prevention

    If you have kidney stones, you may need to follow a special diet plan. First, your healthcare professional will run blood and urine tests to find out what kind of risk factors you may have. Then your healthcare professional will tell you the diet changes and medical treatment you need to prevent having kidney stones come back.

    A registered kidney dietitian can help you make the necessary changes in your diet plan and lifestyle.

    Cranberry Juice Flushes Kidney Stones

    Diet Tips to Prevent Calcium Oxalate Kidney Stones

    MYTH BUSTED: Cranberry juice is great if you have a urinary tract infection or to prevent one. It solidifies your urine which flushes an infection out and prevents them. If you have a kidney stone, however, it makes the problem exponentially worse. Cranberry contains high amounts of oxalate, which causes kidney stones. So the next time you get kidney stone symptoms, pass on the cranberry if you want to pass those stones.

    Also Check: Renal Diet Orange Juice

    Myths About Kidney Stones

    If youve ever gotten a kidney stone you know that its not like a nagging cough, it is quite painful and in extreme cases can even require surgery to correct. The rumors that people spread about what a kidney stone experience is like can be quite frightening but the fact is most of these rumors are just that rumors. Its important to know, however, if the what you are experiencing are actual kidney stone symptoms, or something else, for example, a urinary tract infection or sometimes just plain old indigestion. When you start buying into these myths that people spread about kidney stones, it can can cause you undue stress or worse, lead you to a treatment that will advance your problem not help it. This is why we want to debunk the top myths about kidney stones so you can better know kidney stone symptoms when you spot them. Keep in mind the main symptoms will be different for everyone but include pain when you urinate, nausea, frequent urination, fevers and cold chills, and pains that come in different intensities and fluctuate. Just because you have one of these symptoms or lack thereof, does not indicate you have kidney stones. For your healths sake dont believe the hype of these kidney stone and treatment myths:

    Soda Causes Kidney Stones

    MYTH BUSTED: While we are tempted to let you believe this one as Soda is a nutrient empty, sugar-laden drink, we must inform you this is NOT the case. The fact is phosphoric acid is the culprit that is an ingredient in SOME sodas, typically colas, and pepper sodas such as Coke or Dr. Pepper and Pepsi. The other issue with Soda is that it is a diuretic because of the caffeine. This makes the salt content in your urine rise, which promotes kidney stones. So have a soda, but also follow it with an equal amount of water and you will decrease that concentrate. Alternatively, you could avoid soda altogether and replace it with healthier alternatives.

    You May Like: Does Red Wine Cause Kidney Stones

    Dairy And Our Kidneys

    When it comes to dairy products in our everyday food intake, most people would say that they have milk or other dairy products daily, if not more! Milk, cheese, cottage cheese, yogurts, pudding and ice cream are some of the favorite dairy products of young and old alike. Dairy products are naturally abundant in protein, B vitamins, calcium, phosphorus and potassium. All of these nutrients are important for our bodys many functions.

    Healthy kidneys help remove waste products and extra fluid from the blood and help balance the levels of salt and minerals in the body. As kidney function declines, protein waste products, fluid, salt and minerals can rise to unsafe levels in the body and this may mean that dairy products must be limited.

    A closer look at these key nutrients in dairy foods will help those with decreased kidney function understand the importance of limiting dairy foods.

    Ways To Reduce Your Risk Of Kidney Stones Forming

    FACT : Dietary calcium does not cause kidney stones. In ...
  • Drink at least 2.5 – 3 litres of fluid every 24 hours. Aim for at least 10 mugs a day or over 3.5 pints. It does not all have to be water – tea, coffee, milk and diluted low sugar juice or flavoured drinks are just as good. Avoiding dehydration is the single most important step to take to avoid kidney stones. Drink regularly out of habit and well before you feel thirsty. Start the day with a large drink. Take a litre bottle of something you like to drink with you to work and drink at least two of these bottles a day. Drink more if you work in a hot environment.
  • Reduce intake of sugary drinks.;Don’t drink sugary drinks that may contain large amounts of fructose corn syrup like normal Cola, Pepsi, energy drinks, lemonade or milkshakes. Excessive dietary fructose has a strong association with calcium oxalate kidney stones. Diet or zero sugar fizzy drinks are fine.
  • Drink milk and eat dairy food.;People who do not drink milk or eat dairy food get stones more often. The calcium in milk also helps prevent bone thinning and hip fractures in later life. Skimmed milk, 1% or semi-skimmed and low fat products are just as high in calcium and as good at preventing stones, but contain less fat. Look at milk and dairy food labels for calcium content. Adults should aim for 700 – 1200mg of calcium a day.
  • Please note this advice only applies to kidney stones in adults and not children.

    Recommended Reading: Red Wine Kidney Stones

    Kidney Stone Diet: Foods To Eat And Avoid


    Kidney stones in the urinary tract are formed in several ways. Calcium can combine with chemicals, such as oxalate or phosphorous, in the urine. This can happen if these substances become so concentrated that they solidify. Kidney stones can also be caused by a buildup of uric acid. Uric acid buildup is caused by the metabolism of protein. Your urinary tract wasnt designed to expel solid matter, so its no surprise that kidney stones are very painful to pass. Luckily, they can usually be avoided through diet.

    If youre trying to avoid kidney stones, what you eat and drink is as important as what you shouldnt eat and drink. Here are some important rules of thumb to keep in mind.


    Most Popular

    Are Beets Bad For Kidneys