Study Summary: Beverages And Their Effect On Kidney Stones
In this epidemiological study on beverages and their impact on kidney stones, researchers followed 194,095 people over the course of eight years. The study was conducted to see if there was any correlation between the type of fluid participants drank, how much of each beverage they drank, and its effect on kidney stones. At the completion of the study, 4,462 people had a kidney stone at one point or another.
Its important to note that none of these participants had a history of kidney stones beforehand.
How The Study Was Conducted
Researchers first established the kidney stone risk level for each participant based on health and dietary factors. The study was broken into three parts, to examine three different sample sizes.
In each part of the study, researchers compared the effects of drinking an average of one or more servings per day against drinking less than one serving per week. A serving is described as
- 12 ounces of soda or beer,
- eight ounces of milk, coffee, tea or fruit punch,
- five ounces of wine or
- four to six ounces of juice
Researchers found that sugar-sweetened colas and non-colas, fruit punch and diet non-cola drinks increased the risk of kidney stones, in some cases up to 33 percent.
On the other hand, beer, white and red wine, caffeinated and decaf coffee, orange juice and tea reduced the risk of kidney stones drastically. Beer proved to reduce the risk of kidney stones up to 41 percent, and wine reduced kidney stone risk by 33 percent.
Kidney Pain Kidney Stones And Kidney Infections: An Alcohol Link
What about the kidney pain some people claim to feel after a night of drinking? According to Dr. Bobart, theres no research to suggest a link between alcohol and kidney pain. But alcohol acts as a diuretic and can leave you dehydrated.
Similarly, theres minimal evidence to suggest that alcohol increases the risk of kidney stones or kidney infections. We do know that people who dont drink enough fluids have a greater chance of developing kidney stones. So, people who drink heavily and are often dehydrated may be at greater risk though the science of alcohols role in kidney stones is still unclear, he adds.
What is clear is that heavy drinking takes a toll on your organs, kidneys included. Many people drink more than they realize. In the U.S., heavy drinking is defined as:
- For women: More than seven drinks per week or more than three drinks in a single day.
- For men: More than 14 drinks per week, or more than four drinks in a single day.
I urge anyone who has any trouble with alcohol to seek medical help, says Dr. Bobart. Doing so is nothing to be ashamed of. We have a lot of avenues to help people, and there are resources out there to get people the help they need.
How To Prevent Alcohol
The best way to prevent alcohol-related kidney stones is to drink in moderation, meaning no more than one drink a day for women and two drinks a day for men. In addition, it is important to keep well-hydrated and avoid dehydration. That said, if your doctor tells you that your kidney stones are formed from uric acid, you may need to avoid alcohol entirely.
Don’t Miss: Ginger Tea Kidney Stones
Can Alcohol Cause Kidney Stones
There is not significant evidence that alcohol directly causes kidney stones. Alcohol use particularly excessive alcohol use in which a woman drinks four or more alcoholic drinks in a single occasion or a man drinks five or more drinks during a single session is, however, linked to the development of a variety of other health problems. Some of these health issues include kidney damage, kidney failure, high blood pressure, various cancers, weakened immune system, mental health problems, social problems, and alcohol use disorders .2,3 Some of these issues directly or indirectly negatively impact the renal system.
Concentrated urine can occur when the body is dehydrateda leading cause of kidney stones.3 Dehydration can occur when people do not drink enough water to help the kidneys remove waste from the blood.3 And though we know alcohol consumption whether it be beer, wines, or spirits can contribute to dehydration, we can not link kidney stone development directly to alcohol use and abuse.
What Is The Main Function Of A Kidney
The kidneys are part of the urinary/renal system, which also includes the ureters, bladder, and urethra. You have 2 kidneys to help to filter waste and water from your blood and turn it into urine so that it can be removed from the body.1, 2, 3, 4
The kidneys ensure that your nerves and muscles work properly by maintaining a delicate balance of water, salts, and minerals. The kidneys release hormones that influence the production of red blood cells, maintain healthy blood pressure, and play a role in strengthening your bones.2, 3
The kidneys work around-the-clock to filter waste, water, and acid out of your blood. This ensures that the proper levels of water, salts, and electrolytesincluding sodium, phosphorus, potassium, and calciumare in your blood.1, 2, 3
This is accomplished through tiny filtering cells known as nephrons that separate the waste products from the substances you need. Proteins, blood cells, nutrients, and minerals that you need are reabsorbed into the bloodstream, while the waste products are turned to urine.3, 4
Read Also: Reducose Weight Loss
What You Can Do To Prevent Kidney Stones
If youâve already had a kidney stone, your doctor may recommend medication to keep it from happening again. What kind will depend on what caused the stone.
Also, take charge of your diet:
- Drink lots of water. Stay hydrated, especially when you exercise.
- Check food labels. Read the ingredients. Avoid or cut back on foods with high amounts of ingredients like sodium chloride, monosodium glutamate , and sodium nitrate.
- Choose foods wisely. Usually itâs good to get more spinach and nuts in your diet. But if you have calcium oxalate stones, which are the most common type, your doctor may tell you to avoid or limit foods high in oxalates:
- Nuts, including almonds, cashews, pistachios, and peanuts
- Soy products, including soy burgers, soy milk, and soy cheese
Treatment Of Kidney Stones
In most instances, people will not require medical assistance for their kidneys stone. People can pass a small stone without even noticing any symptoms. In fact, most stones pass out of the body without any help. It is only when these stones are difficult to pass that the individual will usually seek help from a doctor. These are some of the available treatments for kidney stones:
* Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy is an effective treatment for large kidney stones. It involves using shock waves that pass through the body and break up the stone.* Ureterorenoscopy may be required if a stone becomes trapped in the urinary tract. It involves passing a thin instrument called an ureteroscope through the urinary tract and using this to remove the stone.* Sometimes it will be necessary to perform surgery. A cut will be made in the back of the individual so that the surgeon can pass an instrument through to the kidney and remove the stone. This type of treatment may be used for particular large stones or when dealing with an individual who is particularly obese.
Also Check: Does Seltzer Water Cause Kidney Stones
Soda Causes Kidney Stones
MYTH BUSTED: While we are tempted to let you believe this one as Soda is a nutrient empty, sugar-laden drink, we must inform you this is NOT the case. The fact is phosphoric acid is the culprit that is an ingredient in SOME sodas, typically colas, and pepper sodas such as Coke or Dr. Pepper and Pepsi. The other issue with Soda is that it is a diuretic because of the caffeine. This makes the salt content in your urine rise, which promotes kidney stones. So have a soda, but also follow it with an equal amount of water and you will decrease that concentrate. Alternatively, you could avoid soda altogether and replace it with healthier alternatives.
Does Beer Prevent Kidney Stones
- /By Matt Smith
I have never had a kidney stone. Passing a kidney stone is supposed to be as painful as giving birth. Considering I have a < 1% of giving birth and a 19% chance of forming a kidney stone, Id like to minimise my risk as much as possible! Ive heard many conflicting opinions on the relationship between beer and kidney stones. Does beer prevent kidney stones? Or does it cause them?
Beer does not directly cause kidney stones. But it can lead to weight gain, dehydration, and increased purine levels, which can theoretically lead to an increased risk. However, studies have shown that drinking beer and wine can reduce your risk of getting kidney stones. Ultimately, there are better ways to reduce your risk of kidney stones.
So, now that we have our answer, it is probably best that I explain myself! How can drinking beer prevent kidney stones while also increasing risk?
You May Like: Aleve Side Effects Kidney
What Causes Kidney Stones
There are many different reasons a person might get kidney stones throughout their life, ranging from genetics to lifestyle.
- Genetics can cause kidney stones, which are often made from cystine.
- Acidic urine can cause kidney stones, often made from uric acid.
- Diet can be linked to kidney stones, often formed from calcium oxalate.
- Infections can cause kidney stones, often formed from struvite.
- Dehydration can cause kidney stones by making it harder to flush out crystals in your urine.
Can Beer Remove Kidney Stones
There are a couple of things you need to keep in mind while consuming alcohol for kidney stones. Following are the main reasons that lead to people thinking that beer is good for kidney stones-
- Some scientific researchers say that drinking moderate amounts of beer can indeed help in reducing the risk of kidney stones. But since people can have varied definitions of moderate, be sure to know what moderate level of consumption is. Just because you read somewhere that beer is good for kidney stones is not a valid reason to start drinking. Some medical professionals say that moderate for women is one drink a day, and for men is two drinks a day. So can beer help with kidney stones? Yes, but only when consumed in a moderate amount.
- Another reason is a myth that answers the question: how does beer help kidney stones? Myth: Since beer causes you to urinate more, it will help you pass the pre-existing stones. Can you believe in a myth?
The second reason also has a valid explanation as to why it is a myth. As mentioned before, beer can cause dehydration, and when the human body is dehydrated, you are less likely to urinate. So instead of passing kidney stones, it will make it harder to move the stones. So, excess beer cannot be an apt choice of fluid to make the kidney stones pass. Drinking plenty of liquids will help with the stones but not beer.
Recommended Reading: Does Diet Soda Cause Kidney Stones
Kidney Stones There Any Side Effects
Didn’t find the answer you are looking for?
Talk to experienced doctor online and get your health questions answered in just 5 minutes.
Internet is not a doctor
Consult with real doctors online
- Private consultation
The question asked on this page is a free question. You can ask a free health question by downloading the Practo app.
Beer Helps In Dissolving Kidney Stones
Can this be true? The answer is No! If you are having kidney stones, medicines prescribed by a qualified physician will help in the process of passing it through the ureter, or crushing it into bits, based on its size and nature. However, there is not much you can do to dissolve it with uncertain home remedies, especially with a pint of beer! If medication doesnt help, your urologist will suggest other options for its removal.
Recommended Reading: Can Kidney Stone Cause Constipation
/5alcohol And Kidney Stones
The kidneys are responsible for filtering harmful substances like alcohol. Alcohol contains a high purine content, a chemical which leads to uric acid and kidney stones. When you drink too much alcohol, the functionality of your kidneys is compromised, and they are not able to flush out the purine. It then gets accumulated in the kidneys, eventually resulting in a kidney stone.
Also Check: What Std Messes With Your Kidneys
Assessment Of Beverage Use
In 1986 and 1991 , participants returned a food-frequency questionnaire that asked about the use of more than 130 foods, beverages, and supplements in nine categories in the previous year, and dietary information was updated every 4 years. The validity and reliability of the self-reported FFQs were shown in subgroups of the main cohorts . The correlation coefficients ranged from 0.55 to 0.84 for sodas.
In the analyses, individuals were divided into categories according to consumption of less than 1 serving per week, 1 serving per week, 24 servings per week, 56 servings per week, and 1 or more servings per day of each individual beverage. The serving size was defined differently for different beverages .
We used the term noncola for carbonated beverages without cola .
Also Check: Orange Juice Renal Diet
What Can You Do
Always check with your healthcare provider to make sure it is safe for you to drink alcohol. Even if it is safe, it is important to drink in moderation. A good guideline is: no more than one to two drinks a day for men and one drink a day for women and people over 65.
If you would like more information, please contact us.
Save this content:
Should You Consume Beer To Pass Kidney Stones
SHOULD YOU CONSUME BEER TO PASS KIDNEY STONES? | MYTHS vs FACTS
Recommended Reading: Apple Cider Vinegar And Cranberry Juice For Kidney Stones
Alcohol And Kidney Stones
Even though there is no direct causality between alcoholism and kidney stones, alcohol still has an impact on the formation of kidney stones. Drinking an excessive amount of alcohol frequently increases the risk of kidney stones substantially. Beer and grain alcohol can cause kidney stones due to their high concentration of purines. Purines are chemical compounds that can lead to uric acid kidney stones. Its because of this risk that creates a connection between alcohol and kidney stones.
Excessively drinking alcohol can also lead to severe dehydration, which is one of the many reasons behind stone formation in the kidney. Calcium oxalate stones in particular can form when someone is dehydrated. Consistently drinking alcohol can create a pattern of dehydration while increasing the chance of kidney stones.
Another factor can also be obesity and weight gain. Regardless of whether it is mild or severe, this alone can increase a persons chance of kidney stones. In the topic of alcohol and kidney stones, alcohol can end up leading to weight gain and may evolve into obesity. This creates a massive risk of kidney stones down the line .
Consuming too much alcohol puts someone at a high risk of stone formation, however drinking a moderate amount can be beneficial. Strangely, white wine, red wine, and some kinds of beer can actually reduce a persons risk of kidney stones. While this can be seen as a positive some may abuse alcohol at an excessive rate .
Benefits Of Alcohol And Kidney Stones
Alcohol does have some benefits other than a reduced risk of kidney stones. Moderate consumption of red wine has been associated with reduced risk of heart disease. This is likely due to the large amount of antioxidants and other bioactive components such as resveratrol and quercetin found in red wine. These antioxidants stop harmful free radicals from harming our bodies and causing damage to our heart and vasculature. Antioxidants can also help reduce cancer risk.
It is important to note that excessive alcohol use is associated with an increased risk of heart disease and many cancers.
Moderate alcohol consumption has also been shown to strengthen social bonds and even trigger release of endorphins. It would be silly to ignore the social benefits of alcohol and the culture around drinking at sporting events, taking a trip to a beautiful vineyard or grabbing a drink with co-workers during happy hour.
You May Like: Is Apple Cider Vinegar Good For Your Kidneys