Erik Charlton/flickr Bi Answers: Is Drinking Carbonated Water The Same As Drinking Regular Water
Carbonated water seems like a great alternative for people who dont like the taste of still water, but who want to stay hydrated throughout the day.
But is the bubbly beverage just as good for your body as the stuff that comes out of the faucet?
Basically, yes. Sparkling water can be just as hydrating as regular water, according to Jennifer McDaniel, a registered dietitian and certified specialist in sports dietetics.
Carbonated or sparkling water is made by dissolving carbon dioxide in water, creating carbonic acid. This process just adds bubbles it does not add sugar, calories, or caffeine. Tonic water, club soda, and mineral water are all types of carbonated water, but these have added sodium, vitamins, or sweeteners, so its important to read the label.
There are some common health concerns associated with drinking carbonated water for instance, that it leaches calcium from the bones, causes kidney stones, and strips the enamel from your teeth but these are not supported by clinical research.
In reality theres no good evidence that carbonated water causes harm to your bone, registered dietitians Jennifer Nelson and Katherine Zeratsky said on the Mayos Clinics blog. The confusion may arise because of research that found a connection between carbonated cola drinks and low bone mineral density.
Does Carbonated Water Cause Kidney Stones
Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers â it’s anonymous and free!
Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers â it’s anonymous and free!
HealthTap doctors are based in the U.S., board certified, and available by text or video.
Types Of Kidney Stones
The different types of stones are made of different types of substances. It’s important to know the type of stone you have, so you can know what may have caused it and how to prevent it.
If you pass a kidney stone, you should take it to your doctor so they can send it to the lab and find out what kind it is:
-
Calcium stones. Most kidney stones are made from calcium, in the form of calcium oxalate. There are two kinds of calcium stones:
-
Calcium oxalate. Oxalate is a substance made daily by your liver. Some fruits and vegetables, as well as nuts and chocolate, are high in it. Your body absorbs the substance when you eat these foods. Other things that can make the concentration of calcium or oxalate in your urine to rise are taking high doses of vitamin D, intestinal bypass surgery and certain metabolic disorders.
-
Calcium phosphate. This type of stone happens more often in people with metabolic conditions, like renal tubular acidosis or with people who take medications to treat migraines or seizures.
Struvite stones. These can form from a urinary tract infection . The bacteria that cause the infection make ammonia build up in your urine. This leads to formation of the stones. The stones can get large very quickly.
Uric acid stones. These form in people who lose too much fluid because of chronic diarrhea or malabsorption eating a high-protein diet or having diabetes or metabolic syndrome. Certain genetic factors also may increase your risk of uric acid stones.
Don’t Miss: Is Vinegar Good For Your Kidneys
What Are The Health Risks Of Calcium And Limescale
Calcium is an essential mineral for the body. Our bones need it and actually also our kidneys. The evidence that tap water hardness influences calcium stone formation is weak.
First of all, to avoid kidney stones the best thing you can do is to drink plenty of water . Drinking extra water dilutes the substances in urine that lead to stones. It may help to include some citrus beverages, like lemonade and orange juice. The citrate in these beverages helps block stone formation.
Secondly, most of the large long term studies show no or very little relationship between hard water and kidney stones. For the general population there simply is no increase risk. There are however people with poor health with an increased risk which is why doctors may give a warning.
If you have kidney stones already then you should follow the advise of your doctor. Bottled water and tap water may contain minerals that are not recommended for consumption by people with kidney stones. Read more.
How Common Are Uric Acid Stones
Researchers estimate that one in 10 people in the United States will have a kidney stone at some point in their lives. Theyre more common in men than women. For men, the lifetime risk is about 19%. For women, its about 9%.
Most people dont get kidney stones before age 30. But many cases can happen earlier in life, even among children.
You May Like: Soda And Kidney Stones
Myths About Limescale In Tap Water And Kidney Stones
Does limescale in tap water cause kidney stones? Will hard water cause other health issues?
About 30% of the population in Spain and Italy are concerned about drinking hard calcium rich water. This is also the case for parts of North America. Are they right to be concerned or is it all just a nocebo?
We decided to find out and debunk the myths.
What Is The Most Flavorful Sparkling Water
The 10 Best Sparkling Waters , According to Taste LaCroix. San Pellegrino. Perrier. Spindrift. Mountain Valley. Poland Spring. Schweppes. Schweppesline of sparkling water beverage has a nice pop and fizz thats creamy in the way it froths. Adirondack Seltzer . Experience something fresh and natural with Adirondack, which is calorie- and sodium-free.
Also Check: Ginger Tea Dissolves Kidney Stones
Don’t Miss: Almond Milk Good For Kidneys
Is Hard Water Dangerous To Drink
What is Hard Water?
Hard water is water containing high concentrations of dissolved minerals, usually calcium or magnesium carbonates , chlorides or sulphates . The hardness of water depends on its source. Groundwater that has been in contact with porous rocks containing deposits of minerals like limestone or dolomite will be very hard, while water from glaciers or flowing through igneous rocks is much softer.
The hardness of water is determined by the milligrams of calcium carbonateper litre and is reported it in parts-per-million . In general, water with less than 60 ppm can be considered soft, water with 60-120 ppm moderately hard, and water with greater than 120 ppm hard. For reference, Montreals water is typically around 116 ppm, or moderately hard, and sea waters hardness is approximately 6,630 ppm since it contains many dissolved salts .
Hard water can interfere with the action of soaps and detergents and can result in deposits of calcium carbonate, calcium sulphate and magnesium hydroxide 2) inside pipes and boilers, causing lower water flows and making for less efficient heating. The ions in hard water can also corrode metal pipes through galvanic corrosion. Water softening filters can circumvent these problems through the use of ion-exchange resins that replace calcium and magnesium ions with sodium and potassium ions. But if one consumes water with higher-than-average concentrations of calcium and magnesium. Is that OK?
Side Effects Of Drinking Softened Water
Listening to manufacturers of water softeners, you only hear of the virtues of water softeners.
Yes, its true!
Water softeners are great.
Nevertheless, there exists some confusion about the effects of drinking softened water. I did my own investigation on the side effects of drinking softened water.
Lets jump right in
My extensive reading of material on the web and medical journals shows that there are three main concerns associated with drinking softened water.
IN THIS POST
Recommended Reading: Can Diet Soda Cause Kidney Stones
What Else Should I Ask My Healthcare Provider
If you have a uric acid stone, ask your provider:
- What treatment will work best?
- Will I need surgery?
- How can I prevent a stone from forming again?
- What diet is right for me?
- Should I avoid any foods or beverages?
- Do I need to take any supplements?
A note from Cleveland Clinic
Uric acid stones are a type of kidney stone. When you have a high level of uric acid in your blood and urine, small stones can form. These stones can block the passage of urine out of your body, causing pain and other symptoms. Many uric acid stones pass on their own. Your provider may prescribe medication to help the stone pass. For larger stones, your provider may recommend noninvasive or minimally invasive procedures. These treatments include shockwave lithotripsy, ureteroscopy and PCNL. Treatments are successful, but uric acid stones may come back. Avoid or limit foods high in purines to reduce your risk. If you have pain in your side, burning when you pee or see blood in your urine, talk to your healthcare provider. The right diagnosis and treatment can help you feel your best.
Last reviewed by a Cleveland Clinic medical professional on 08/19/2021.
References
The Stages Of Chronic Kidney Disease Are As Follow:
Stage 1: GFR count more than 90 mL/minStage 2: Mild kidney loss GFR between 60 and 89 mL/minStage 3: Moderate decrease in kidney work,Stage 4: Severe kidney harm with GFR dropping between 15-29 mL/minStage 5: Kidney disappointment with GFR reduced to 15 mL/min
Stage 3 of CKD denotes your kidneys are mostly damaged and you need to work on your diet to restore their function.
Carbonated water contains phosphoric acid and has been linked to urinary changes, a reason you may have your kidney damaged. During stage 3, your kidneys have got their function reduced to act normal. The main reason why you should avoid drinking carbonated beverages or cola beverages is that they have been associated with diabetes, hypertension, and kidney stones. Is carbonated water bad for stage 3 kidney disease.
- Carbonated water is a type of flat water with flavored carbon dioxide gas while the other carbonated water such as soda usually has added minerals, and tonic water may also contain added sugar. During chronic kidney disease, consuming such beverages will only going to worse your high-blood pressure and blood sugar .
- Further, the harmful effects of having a cola or carbonated beverage on your kidney may include:
- Carbonated water is ought to have a negative impact on bone health because of the phosphoric acid in the soft drinks.
If you are facing gastric reflux because of CKD, then taking carbonated beverage is going to aggravate the condition.
Don’t Miss: Kidney Pain Std
Promote Good Bowel Movements
Another benefit of drinking more water is that you promote better bowel movements and a healthier digestive system. Another link was found between dehydration and constipation in people of all ages.
Not only can drinking more water help relieve constipation, but researchers have also concluded that drinking carbonated water is more helpful than spring water in reducing the effects of constipation.
Can You Filter Softened Water For Drinking
Drinking softened water is perfectly safe for your family. However, soft water is more susceptible to getting contaminated with toxic metals from pipes in the plumbing system because softened water is more corrosive.
If you are worried about poisoning from toxic metals such as lead, you can filter softened water before drinking it. The filters that are good for removing toxic metals are reverse osmosis water filter filters. The reverse Osmosis system will remove 98% of sodium that is added to softened water.
You May Like: Ginger Tea Kidney Stones
Causes Of Kidney Stones
Kidney stones happen when your pee has a high concentration of minerals and other substances — like calcium, oxalate, and uric acid — that come together to make crystals. Crystals stick together to make one or more stones. Stones happen when your urine doesnât have enough fluid and other substances to keep them from happening.
A kidney stone can be as tiny as a grain of sand, and you can pass it without ever knowing. But a bigger one can block your urine flow and hurt a lot. Some people say the pain can be worse than childbirth.
Different things can bring on kidney stones, including what you eat and certain medications. If you or someone in your family has had a kidney stone, youâre more likely to have them.
How Else Can I Prevent Uric Acid Stones
You can take other steps to prevent uric acid stones:
- Drink at least 12 cups of fluids every day, preferably water.
- Maintain a healthy weight.
- Follow the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension diet, which can reduce both high blood pressure and the risk of kidney stones.
- Take any medications your provider prescribed to prevent uric acid stones from forming.
Don’t Miss: Is Pomegranate Juice Good For Your Kidneys
Does Our Body Absorb Minerals From Hard Water
On average, our bodies absorb around 50% of the minerals in drinking water. Surprisingly, minerals from water contribute 5-20% of the total amount of minerals we eat!
The amount of calcium absorbed from hard water is very different between people. Intestinal absorption of calcium is highly dependent on how much calcium your body needs. For example, if your body needs more calcium, it will absorb a greater percentage of calcium from your food. Other factors, such as vitamin D status, also impact calcium absorption.
Carbonated Water And Kidney Stones
As the Mayo Clinic explains, kidney stones are hard deposits made from minerals and salts that can form inside your kidneys, like calcium, struvite, uric acid and cystine. A variety of factors can contribute to kidney stone development, but the stones occur when your urine contains more crystal-forming substances and not enough fluid to dilute it.
Common kidney stone symptoms include severe pain in your back and sides, pain while urinating, urine that is red, brown, pink, cloudy or foul-smelling and pain that comes in waves and/or fluctuates in intensity. You either pass kidney stones through urinating, or have larger stones treated with sound waves to break them up into smaller pieces.
You might be at a higher risk for developing kidney stones if you have a family history of kidney stones, are dehydrated, are obese, live with certain digestive disease or eat a diet that is high in fat, sodium or sugar.
Read more:Are There Health Benefits of Soda and Carbonated Water?
Sodium in particular plays a role in kidney stones, the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases says. Adults should aim to consume less than 2,300 milligrams of salt per day, but the average person has a much higher sodium intake of more than 3,400 milligrams per day.
You May Like: Ginger Good For Kidney
Damage To Hair And Skin
Many people spend tons of money on products to maintain the health of their skin and hair. As consumers, we are searching for the best shampoo for our hair, the best soap to leave our skin silky soft, and the best body washes out there for our children. You can spend all the money in the world on these products but if you have hard water in your house, those products wont be as helpful as clean water. When you or your family showers in hard water, you can feel it on your skin and hair. The hard water reduces moisture and leaves behind a film that makes it feel dirty to the touch. You may also begin to build up dandruff in your hair and, over time, develop skin complications such as eczema.
Is Carbonated Water Bad For Stage 3 Kidney Disease
Kidney disease refers to the incapacity of the kidneys to perform the required function of filtering blood for the removal of waste. Chronic kidney disease is the undemanding loss of kidney function over a couple of months or years. The damage moderately happens in the initial stages of CKD while in the late stages, kidneys become incapable of working out some important things for you. This happens in stages according to the glomerular filtration rate that signifies how well your kidneys are eliminating toxins and unwanted. The count of GFR depicts which stage of chronic kidney disease you are in.Is carbonated water bad for stage 3 kidney disease.
Dont Miss: Is Celery Juice Good For Kidneys
Don’t Miss: Seltzer Water Kidney Stones
Your Teeth Could Suffer But Moderation And Washing Down With Water Helps
Seltzer is indeed, harsh on your teeth, but not if you drink it right .
The problem with seltzer is that it can be acidic, says Dr. Lee Gause, a dentist who specializes in implant and cosmetic dentistry and founder of Smile Design Manhattan. Teeth fare better in a neutral or even slightly alkaline solution. Different seltzer brands have different levels of acidity, primarily stemming from both the citric acid that gives seltzers the bubbles and zesty lemony taste. Even unflavored seltzers contain a carbonic acid that gives it its bubbles.
Over time, that acidity can lead to enamel erosion.
I have seen a lot of patients whose main cause of erosion was an overly acidic diet from citrus to sodas and lack of regular or alkaline water, says Dr. Gause. All of that being said, is safe to consume in appropriate volumes keep it to once a day with meals, at a maximum, and be sure to wash everything down with standard water.
Grause also recommends using a straw if you want to be extra careful, as this allows the seltzer to bypass your teeth.
Recommended Reading: What Laxative Is Safe For Kidneys
How To Avoid Kidney Stones
Here are the five ways to help prevent kidney stones:
Drink plenty of water: Drinking extra water dilutes the substances in urine that lead to stones. Strive to drink enough fluids to pass 2 liters of urine a day, which is roughly eight standard 8-ounce cups. It may help to include some citrus beverages, like lemonade and orange juice. The citrate in these beverages helps block stone formation.
Eat calcium rich foods: Dietary calcium binds to oxalate in your intestines and thereby decreases the amount of oxalate that gets absorbed into the bloodstream and then excreted by the kidney. This lowers the concentration of oxalate in the urine, so there is less chance it can bind to urinary calcium. That leads to decreased risk of kidney stones.
Reduce sodium: A high-sodium diet can trigger kidney stones because it increases the amount of calcium in your urine. So, a low-sodium diet is recommended for the stone prone. Current guidelines suggest limiting total daily sodium intake to 2,300 mg. If sodium has contributed to kidney stones in the past, try to reduce your daily intake to 1,500 mg. This will also be good for your blood pressure and heart.
Avoid stone-forming foods: Beets, chocolate, spinach, rhubarb, tea, and most nuts are rich in oxalate, which can contribute to kidney stones. If you suffer from stones, your doctor may advise you to avoid these foods or to consume them in smaller amounts.
Read Also: Is Apple Cider Vinegar Good For Your Kidneys