Thursday, June 27, 2024
HomeStoneDoes Protein Cause Kidney Stones

Does Protein Cause Kidney Stones

What Causes Kidney Stones To Form

Does A High Protein Diet Cause Kidney Damage or Stones (Clinical Evidence Included)

Kidney stones form when chemicals within an individual’s urine become concentrated enough to form crystals . As these crystals grow larger, they can travel to the urinary tract and get stuck blocking the flow of urine. This can be extremely painful. Dehydration is also a key factor in causing any type of kidney stone to form. For those who have previously suffered from a kidney stone, drinking 2 litres of fluid a day can greatly reduce the likelihood of a reoccurrence by almost 50%

. Calcium binds with oxalate in the intestine reducing the amount excreted by the kidneys into the urine. With lower oxalate levels in the urine there is less opportunity for it to bind with calcium and create crystals which can turn into kidney stones .

Another concern with high protein diets, is some studies have linked a high protein diet to increasing the levels of acid on the kidneys. High levels of acidity around the kidneys can increase the likelihood of kidney stones forming .

Can Too Much Whey Protein Cause Kidney Stones

The University of Connecticut did a study called Dietary Protein Intake and Renal Function, which found that persons with healthy kidneys who consume a lot of whey protein shouldnt be concerned.

According to the study, recent research on high-protein diets for weight reduction and athletics has revealed no harmful effects on renal function. According to the studys findings, no indication increased protein intake causes kidney injury or functioning.

Tip : Dont Forget To Check Sodium

Keeping sodium in check is an important part of kidney stone prevention. Bread can be surprisingly high in sodium.

Always check the Nutrition Facts label to see how much sodium is in your bread. Both the general recommendations for healthy people, and people with kidney stones, suggest limiting sodium to no more than 2,300mg per day.

Recommended Reading: Stds That Affect Kidneys

You May Like: What Blood Test For Kidney Function

What Causes Kidney Stones

Across the different types of kidney stones, there are several different causes, including :

  • Extreme diets
  • When we think about protein powder, most of those dont apply. Hydration, calcium, sodium, and extreme dieting are all separate aspects.

    Kidney stones can be caused my many lifestyle factors diet is only one. Protein powder can only potentially affect protein intake and oxalate intake.

    Does Not Test The Acid Load Hypothesis

    Does High Protein Cause Kidney Damage or Stones

    The negative result does not invalidate the idea that protein can promote stones via acid load. But it does demonstrate that the acid loading from actual ranges of protein intake are not sufficient to vary kidney stone risk. In other words, they have tested the relevance of protein under common conditions in relation to stone risk, but not the underlying mechanism of acid load promoting stones as a basic physiology.

    Recommended Reading: Can Aleve Damage Your Kidneys

    Correlates Of Diet Potassium

    As a kind of gift, the data of excellent science often enough give us useful or at least eye opening glimpses of how things work. Here are four urine measurements central in kidney stone diagnostic evaluation plotted as a function of diet potassium intake that means veggies and fruits for the most part. The authors tell us that stone formers and controls scarcely differed, so they offer the pooled values.

    In all four plots, the big blue dots are medians, the lines the 95% confidence limits. All four trends were significant at p< 0.001.

    Acid Loads Apart From Protein Raise Urine Calcium

    I would be remiss to leave matters as if Fentons meta-analysis were a sufficient guide to this vast literature. Her approach emphasizes the quality of the human trials. Another review more emphasizes the underlying technical problems of assessing net acid base balance. In this work acid base balance was altered by NH4Cl , methionine , egg white , beef , soy protein , deprived of KHCO3 , given KHCO3 , or given NaHCO3 by replacing some of the dietary NaCl and maintaining Na intake constant .

    Despite the differing formalisms and even scientific instincts of the investigators who reviewed the topic the overall result is amazingly uniform. For example at about -50 net acid excretion, there would be about 50 mg less urine calcium and at about 200 mEq of extra acid about 300 mg more urine calcium in both studies alike.

    Whereas the Fenton points easily fit a linear regression, the larger range of the Lemann review shows the response is not linear but has a curving character. If you look closely at the Fenton points there is indeed a slight sag around 0 meaning that perhaps a curving regression might have a higher multiple R2.

    The point of showing all this is obvious: However you review the papers, acid loads increase and alkali loads reduce urine calcium, meaning this is a vigorous phenomenon, not some houseplant that cannot stand up to the weather. It has been found in many laboratories over many decades, in humans shown in these two figures and animals alike.

    You May Like: How Does A Girl Get A Kidney Infection

    Assessment Of Urinary Composition

    Twenty-fourhour urine samples were collected in three cycles. In the first cycle, participants were eligible if they were 70 years of age in the HPFS or 65 years of age in the NHS I and had no history of cancer or cardiovascular disease. In the second cycle, participants were eligible if they were 75 years of age and had no history of cancer . The third cycle was performed only by the participants in the NHS II, with the following criteria: age 55 years old, white race, and no history of high BP, coronary heart disease, or cancer. Urine samples collected in the first two cycles were analyzed with the system provided by Mission Pharmacal , whereas the samples collected in the third cycle were analyzed by the Litholink Corporation . Participants with a history of kidney stones were oversampled in the first two cycles.

    Participants with possible over- or undercollections were removed from the analysis. For participants who provided more than one collection, the first sample was analyzed.

    How Can You Tell If There Is Protein In Your Urine

    Does Creatine cause Kidney Stones?

    If you have kidney damage and protein is escaping into your urine, you may notice the following symptoms:

    • Swelling in your face, abdomen or hands and feet.
    • Urine that appears bubbly, foamy or frothy.

    If you notice either of these symptoms, talk to your doctor about the cause and what the best treatment may be. In some cases, the issue will resolve on its own without further treatment.

    Read Also: Is Magnesium Good For Kidneys

    How It Is Done

    A routine urine test can be done in your doctorâs office, clinic, or lab. You may also be asked to collect a urine sample at home and bring it with you to the office or lab for testing.

    Collecting a urine sample from a small child or baby is done by using a special plastic bag with tape around its opening. The bag is placed around the childâs genitals until he or she urinates. Then you carefully remove the bag. To collect a urine sample from a very sick baby, a doctor may use a urinary catheter through the urethra or a needle through the babyâs belly directly into the bladder .

    Read Also: Can Apple Cider Vinegar Affect Your Kidneys

    I Feel Ive A Stone What Do I Do

    See a health care provider as quickly as doable. Its possible youll be requested to drink further fluid in an try and flush out the stone out within the urine. For those who pressure your urine and may save a bit of the stone that has handed, deliver it to your physician. Or, the stone could have to be eliminated with surgical procedure.

    protein in urine and kidney stones

    Read Also: How Painful Is Passing A Kidney Stone

    Studies On High Protein Intake And Kidney Health

    We will now take a look at four relevant randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews.

    In each of these papers, the researchers were trying to establish whether too much dietary protein can damage the kidneys, and what risks high protein diets may have.

    1. A High Protein Diet Has No Harmful Effects: A One-Year Crossover Study in Resistance-Trained Males

    In this randomized controlled study, Jose Antonio of the International Society of Sports Nutrition led research into potential harms of a high-protein diet in resistance-trained individuals .

    The study lasted for 12 months in total, and participants consumed between 2.51 and 3.32 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight every day.

    Notably, this level of protein intake is 3-4 times higher than the current dietary guidelines recommended daily allowance .

    During the 12-month period, participants visited a laboratory five times for comprehensive testing.

    The results showed no negative effects, and there was no adverse change in kidney function or other health markers.

    Key Point:

    What Do My Test Results Mean

    Does High Protein Cause Kidney Damage or Stones

    Test results may vary depending on your age, gender, health history, the method used for the test, and other things. Your test results may not mean you have a problem. Ask your healthcare provider what your test results mean for you.

    Results are given in milligrams . Normal urine protein in adults is less than 150 mg within a 24-hour period.

    Also Check: Can You Put Protein Powder In Overnight Oats

    Also Check: Can You Live With Kidney Failure

    Lower Your Animal Protein Intake

    Many sources of protein, such as red meat, pork, chicken, poultry, and eggs, increase the amount of uric acid you produce. Eating large amounts of protein also reduces a chemical in urine called citrate. Citrates job is to prevent the formation of kidney stones. Alternatives to animal protein include quinoa, tofu , hummus, chia seeds, and Greek yogurt. Since protein is important for overall health, discuss how much you should eat daily with your doctor.

    Can Pea Protein Cause Acne

    When youre working hard to get lean and healthy, the last thing you want to deal with is acne. Unfortunately, acne breakouts and protein seem to go hand in hand especially if that protein comes from whey.¹

    Why? Because whey protein powders have been linked to an uptick in acne. When extracted from cows milk, whey may affect several hormonal growth factors, which studies suggest may exacerbate breakouts.²

    You might ask, can pea protein cause acne? This is one of the myths about pea protein that are circulating the Internet. Fortunately, pea protein comes from plants and does not contain acne-triggering hormones. Instead, this clean source of protein offers the complete range of amino acids necessary for muscle health and energy, without the disruptive hormones. In short, pea protein can help keep your skin clear and healthy.

    Donât Miss: Medical Term For Kidneys

    Also Check: Can You Have A Child With One Kidney

    Dietary Protein And Bone Health

    Aging leads to progressive bone loss, which may result in osteoporosis. This is becoming an epidemic disease, with 1 in 4 women > 70 y of age having at least one fracture in their lifetime . The global increase in individuals suffering from osteoporosis means that modifiable factors such as nutrition are of paramount importance. An increase in protein recommendations to > 0.8 g/ for the aging population may be beneficial, because protein utilization is less efficient in the elderly, and age-related bone loss is progressive and can lead to osteoporosis and fracture risk .

    IGF-1 modulates bone homeostasis by promoting osteoblast activity and stimulating renal phosphate resorption . There is a huge amount of evidence of the positive effect of IGF-1 on human bone health. This includes a decrease in the urinary bone resorption markers deoxypyridinoline and N-telopeptide , a decrease in proximal femur bone mineral density loss in the elderly with a recent hip fracture, and a positive association with BMD in several skeletal structures . Dietary protein benefits bone health through IGF-1 secretion. A positive correlation between protein consumption and serum IGF-1 concentration has been established . Moreover, the quality and quantity of the ingested protein may influence serum IGF-1 concentration, because a higher concentration was identified in subjects consuming high-quality protein .

    Protein And Kidney Disease

    Is Protein Powder Bad For You? | Acne, Hair Loss and Kidney Damage

    If you have chronic kidney disease, kidney function is already decreased. Because of this, you have to be extra careful with how much work you make your kidneys do. Healthy kidneys can handle the extra load of excess protein, but damaged kidneys can’t. According to the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, eating more protein than you need makes your kidneys work harder, and this can speed up the progression of kidney disease.

    On the other hand, a March 2018 report in Chronic Diseases and Translational Medicine notes that a low-protein diet may slow the progression of kidney damage in those with moderate to advanced kidney disease or failure. Another report published in PLOS One in November 2018 had the same findings. Researchers also concluded that eating less protein can help improve heart health in those with chronic kidney disease.

    You May Like: How To Tell If Kidney Infection Is Getting Worse

    How Much Protein Should You Be Eating Per Day

    In recent years, many people have begun to increase their protein intake in an effort to aid weight loss and/or build muscle, but how much protein should you be eating every day?

    Though the ideal amount of protein you should be consuming is slightly uncertain – the most common recommendation is 0.8 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight. So if you weighed 60kg, youd need about 48g per day. If you are choosing high protein foods, be sure to opt for healthier options such as whole grains, eggs, and lean meats rather than high-fat meats or processed sources.

    Before starting a new diet plan, its important to seek medical advice and speak with your healthcare provider.

    Know Your Recommended Protein Intake

    For this reason, it is important to be aware of how much protein you need based on your body weight. This helps ensure that you get enough of this macronutrient. It also prevents you from getting so much that it stresses the kidneys unnecessarily.

    The Mayo Clinic recommends that people following a 2,000-calorie diet consume 50 to 175 grams of protein per day. This is based on 0.8 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight.

    For people who are more physically active, higher protein amounts are generally needed. Active individuals should get between 1.1 and 1.5 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight. Those who lift weights would benefit from 1.2 to 1.7 grams per kilogram of body weight daily.

    You May Like: What Does Leaking Kidneys Mean

    Past Fears Of Animal Protein Seem Bogus

    No one questions that massive protein excess can raise urine calcium. So, enough protein 0.8 gm/kg/d and not too much no more than 1 gm/kg/d seems as prudent for stone formers as for the rest of the US, which matches the general US recommendation for us all.

    As for the protein in milk products, it is not any risk at all.But either way, from acid or not, within the range of large numbers of people over long time periods these investigators find no support for animal protein intake per se as a cause of stones. That dairy proteins may have minimal protective effects could be related to the calcium that accompanies it, or perhaps other factors in milk products but the effects are small.

    Dr Eric Taylor kindly read this article, at my request, and accepts my account as accurate. I thank him personally for going to this effort. Since his reading, I have slightly modified the logic of the first several sections with regards to their testing of the acid theory of protein stone genesis, but the main lines of this review remain unaltered.

    Common Symptoms Of Kidney Stones

    Protein Myths Busted! Is protein dangerous? Do they cause kidney stones ...

    Some people can have kidney stones with no symptoms and pass it with ease, maybe never even have realized it was happening. Other people will experience intense pain in the side, back, or groin, nausea and vomiting, and pain when urinating. Burning when you pee, as well as cloudy red or pink urine, can also indicate that you have a kidney stone. If you do experience these symptoms you should reach out to your doctor immediately for the next steps on diagnosis and treatment.

    Also Check: Does Kidney Cancer Spread Quickly

    Can Pea Protein Cause Upset Stomach

    Another one of the top myths about pea protein is that it can cause an upset stomach, or be hard to digest. Fortunately, pea protein is highly digestible, ranking at an impressive 98 percent on the digestibility rating scale. This means that, for most people, pea protein should not cause an upset stomach or make you feel sick. Because pea protein lacks common food allergens, such as dairy, wheat, and nuts, its a better choice for those with food sensitivities or allergies.

    For the many people that experience dairy intolerance, ingesting milk-based products leads to upset stomach, pain and even diarrhea, as their bodies cannot easily digest dairy. Pea protein offers an alternative. Free from dairy and other common irritants, Nuzestâs pea protein offers a clean choice for those with food allergies, vegans and vegetarians alike.

    Kidney Stone Diet: Foods To Eat And Avoid


    Kidney stones in the urinary tract are formed in several ways. Calcium can combine with chemicals, such as oxalate or phosphorous, in the urine. This can happen if these substances become so concentrated that they solidify. Kidney stones can also be caused by a buildup of uric acid. Uric acid buildup is caused by the metabolism of protein. Your urinary tract wasnt designed to expel solid matter, so its no surprise that kidney stones are very painful to pass. Luckily, they can usually be avoided through diet.

    If youre trying to avoid kidney stones, what you eat and drink is as important as what you shouldnt eat and drink. Here are some important rules of thumb to keep in mind.

    Don’t Miss: What Happens To Your Body When You Have Kidney Failure


    Most Popular